These transcripts do not say what the government says they say.

The government is trying to put Jose in the same box, but it just doesn't fit.

This is especially brutal to Jose after he spent more than three years in a military brig without charges.

A fair review of these telephone calls leads to the conclusion that these two men had no idea where this man Ibrahim was.

His confinement went far beyond what any American citizen has ever had to endure without charges being filed against them.

There is simply no evidence to suggest that Jose Padilla has ever engaged in any violent actions toward any one in this country or any other country.

Weak isn't even the right word.

The government is attempting to build a circumstantial case against this man after holding him for 3 1/2 years.